Why did dutch kill micah.

Fact 1 - John was not killed in a bank robbery, but was captured and sent to prison. Abigail was not arrested. Fact 2 - Dutch was in no hurry to save John from prison and was extremely angry at the fact of his release. Fact 3 - John was cast when he. fell off the train, and Dutch said he was most likely dead.Jokes aside, there are a plethora of theories and ideas as to why Dutch Van Der Linde killed Micah Bell. Especially as to why he did it so late in the video game. ... Why did Dutch choose Micah? Micah Was The Newcomer In The Van der Linde Gang. John, similarly, became a Van der Linde member at age 12 …Dutch and Micah probably knew or sensed more than the others is my take on it. pink_life69. •. Micah is straight up calling him Black Lung, he damn well knew Arthur had TB. Dutch also mentions that “he’s not well” (as in Arthur) before some major action. The rest of the gang only might have had a hunch. ImpKing0. Ignoring Dutch going crazy, Micah shot Grimshaw because she took her eyes off of him and let her guard down. Dutch “ignored” this because they were in a standoff, and this was commonplace for the situation. If Arthur shot Micah, then everyone else would have opened fire, most likely resulting in John getting killed.

Dutch shoots Micah. At some point during or prior to 1907, Dutch reunites with Micah, who is now in charge of his own gang, and together they finally retrieve the money from the failed ferry robbery.Sometime later, in 1907, John, Sadie, and Charles storm Mount Hagen in order to get revenge on Micah for his betrayal of the gang. After Sadie appears while …1 Killed Arthur Morgan. Even before outing Micah as a snitch, Arthur was one of Bell's greatest adversaries. As Morgan notices early on what a terrible human being Micah is. Also, it doesn't matter how close Bell gets to Dutch, or how much power he gains in the group, Arthur is never afraid to stand up to him.Micah’s actions in Strawberry actually suggest that he wasn’t a rat at that time. He got into trouble in the first place by killing two people in a bar fight, after seeing some people who he knew. At no point does Lenny say that he was turned or that the people he met were Pinkertons - undercover or not. Just Micah being Micah.

Why did Dutch shoot Micah instead of John? However, Dutch is a narcisstic egomaniac who would not admit that he was fooled so easily, so he kept that knowledge hidden from others. Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for …John was forced to go after his old gang, (Dutch included) as Ross & Co had told him that if he did his family would be killed (or words that that effect) - even at the end he didn't want to kill Dutch, (Little hazzy but i don't believe he killed any of the old gang) he did try to get Dutch to see sense and to come peacefully, Dutch …

Dutch was not up on the mountain to kill Micah at first, I think they were “working together”, Dutch being fooled by Micah into thinking some big score was coming and then Micah planning to turn him over to the Pinkertons. When he saw that John/Sadie/Charles shot their way up the mountain just to kill Micah, Dutch knew he had to either turn ... Micah was probably a rat from the beginning. If he wasn’t there, The Blackwater Massacre wouldn’t have been as bad as it was. Micah actually encouraged Dutch to shoot Heidi. So it was Micah who began Dutch’s downfall. Heidi McCourt was the gang’s hostage. So when she was killed, a bloody, violent gunfight ensued on the ferry and in the ... When Florida-based Chetu hired a telemarketer in the Netherlands, the company demanded the employee turn on his webcam. The employee wasn’t happy with being monitored “for 9 hours ...Feb 24, 2024 · Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Why didn’t Dutch let Arthur kill Micah? As soon as Arthur was about to grab his gun, Dutch steps on his hand to avoid shooting Micah because Dutch believed that Micah was the only loyal gang ... Matthews is a con artist who tried to rob Dutch, and funny enough, Dutch had the same intentions. Both Dutch and Hosea are the gang's founding members, and then Arthur eventually joined them very early on. When it comes to mysteries, the infamous Blackwater ferry heist is something we need to delve into.

We don’t know. Dutch is a talker so maybe he’s searching for the safest wat to kill Micah and get all the money out of the heavily guarded camp. This would make Dutch after Arthur’s death a much more likeable and reasonable character. …

After Sadie gets stabbed, John Marston heads up further into the mountains to confront Micah who was also accompanied by Dutch Van Der Linde. As Micah attemp...

Joshua. Advertisement. In Red Dead Redemption 2, players take on the role of Arthur Morgan, an outlaw member of the Dutch Van der Linde gang. One of the key members of the gang is Micah Bell, a cruel and violent man who Arthur is often at odds with. There is also Dutch, the gang’s leader, who is a more level-headed but equally ruthless ...Theorizing that he knows Micah betrayed him, as he does turn his back on Micah when Arthur dies in the good ending, Dutch probably came up there to kill Micah. Did Dutch know Micah was a rat? No. Dutch only realized Micah was the rat by 1907, far too late to save Arthur.May 31, 2021 · By Charlie Stewart. Published May 31, 2021. Micah Bell is the only member of the Van der Linde Gang John Marston has to kill, which speaks to an overarching theme in Red Dead Redemption. John ... Dutch Van Der Linde, the leader of the Van Der Linde gang, was a treacherous and violent man who betrayed his followers in Red Dead Redemption 2. He would have turned on …Mar 3, 2024 · Why did Dutch shoot Micah? However, Dutch is a narcisstic egomaniac who would not admit that he was fooled so easily, so he kept that knowledge hidden from others. Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son. Mar 3, 2024 · Why did Dutch shoot Micah? However, Dutch is a narcisstic egomaniac who would not admit that he was fooled so easily, so he kept that knowledge hidden from others. Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son. 8. Wagwan piffting23 · 9/6/2020. I think it’s a combination of knowing Micah was a rat and revenge for Arthur. After eight years, Dutch has almost certainly come to terms with the fact that Micah betrayed him. Even in 1899, by the end, he probably knew, as he doesn’t follow Micah. Dutch was the creator of the Van der Linde gang, and as ...

The Pinkertons were killing/capturing outlaws, and Micah was looking for a payout. Killing Cornwall (who hired Pinkertons) is just on brand by that point, and the Pinkertons had already attempted to kill him. It's easy to offer amnesty, ... What micah did, did not help. But Dutch's decisions are the main cause of the gang's downfall.Fact 1 - John was not killed in a bank robbery, but was captured and sent to prison. Abigail was not arrested. Fact 2 - Dutch was in no hurry to save John from prison and was extremely angry at the fact of his release. Fact 3 - John was cast when he. fell off the train, and Dutch said he was most likely dead. Users share their opinions and theories on why Dutch shot Micah when John came to confront him in the epilogue 2 of Red Dead Redemption 2. Some suggest Dutch was a sociopath, others argue he changed over time, and some cite clues from the game. When Dutch killed Brontë, he killed him because Brontë thought he was better than Dutch, and Dutch couldn’t stand it. At that point, Arthur and John realized that Dutch was a very ego-driven man, and that’s why he did everything he did. Not because he was Robin Hood, but because he thought he was better than everyone else. That’s why.Not sure of the "general consensus" but I personally didn't think it was wrong of John to go after Micah. My good reasons : A). Micah was a rat. B). Micah was a goddamn rat. But honestly it even made more sense in the whole redemption undertone the story of RDR1 was supposed to have especially after you've played RDR2.

Fact 1 - John was not killed in a bank robbery, but was captured and sent to prison. Abigail was not arrested. Fact 2 - Dutch was in no hurry to save John from prison and was extremely angry at the fact of his release. Fact 3 - John was cast when he. fell off the train, and Dutch said he was most likely dead.

That's why when Arthur was dying at his feet he stuttered, because he suddenly realized how much he ducked up. It is also why he was on the mountain with Micha in the end. When John asks Dutch what he was doing there he said "same as you I suppose". He was there to kill Micha because in his mind that would avenge Arthur, Hosea and the rests deaths. Dutch felt guilty for what Micah did and gave John the benefit of the doubt - as they were both there to kill Micah. But by RDR John is working for the Government - something Dutch cannot abide. John is hunting former VDL members, including Dutch. That makes John as much of a betrayer in Dutch's eyes as Micah ever was. Jan 24, 2019 ... What Happens If You DON'T Shoot Micah At The End Of The Epilogue In Red Dead Redemption 2? (RDR2) ▻Cheap GTA 5 Shark Cards & More Games: ...#reddeadredemption #reddeadredemtion2Dutch tells John that he had been at Micah's hideout for the "same reason", strongly suggesting that his decision to kill Micah was premeditated. In a unique scenario that cannot be seen under normal circumstances, if John has invincibility (with the use of mods) and kills Dutch, Micah will respond with "Always was slow..", then …Micah prevents Dutch from ever actually being challenged, because all it took for Dutch to hold fast to his ideals was one person to affirm his beliefs. Micah is the devil on Dutch's shoulder ... The factions are: Dutch/Javier/Bill, Micah/Cleet/Joe, Arthur/John, and then an army of Pinkertons trying to kill all of them. Dutch can turn against Micah, make it so its him and Bill and Javier vs. thee other groups, or he can keep them on his side until he escapes. Arthur even says in the John ending that Dutch knows Micah is a rat. Yes he was the rat. This has been confirmed time and time again with a surplus of evidence. Micah started to rat on the gang after they returned from Guarma, not before. Micah never cared for the gang, he never cared for Dutch either. Micah only cared for Micah!

10. [deleted] • 5 yr. ago. Maybe dutch got fed up with him and did it. 6. motsakalis117. • 5 yr. ago. it could have been an acident so they might have been robbing something (train, house, bank) then it would have gone wrong (idk tons of lawmen turnup) and dutch acidentally shoots colms brother then colm retaliates and kills annabelle. 5.

These are the relationships Dutch van der Linde has had prior to and throughout the events of Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2. Dutch and Hosea were close friends for more than two decades. The duo formed the Van der Linde gang together. Hosea’s relationship with Dutch was tested by their disagreements over how to make money, as Hosea’s preference for non-violence, such as ...

So, why did Dutch wait to kill Micah? Fans have several theories. One common Red Dead Redemption 2 theory is that Dutch Van Der Linde suffers from mental health issues, which seems likely. This is why he behaves so erratically in both Red Dead Redemption 2 and the original Red Dead Redemption game.Related: Why Red Dead Redemption 3 Is Almost A Certainty. The mission reportedly got off to a good start, but it was not long until the entire gang was swarmed by Pinkertons. Players learn that, in the heat of the fight, Dutch killed an innocent woman, something players later realize is not out of character for Dutch. …Where does Dutch go after killing Micah? Dutch Van der Linde walks away unharmed at the end of Red Dead Redemption 2 after helping John and Sadie put an end to Micah. He simply walks away at the end of the game. In the original title, however, John manages to track down and kill Dutch, who had created a new gang of Native Americans.Dutch’s main thing was loyalty, he wanted the whole gang to stay with him, in highlight of his speech in chapter 1. But it just doesn’t make sense. in the good ending, dutch turns his back on Micah. but then in the epilogue, dutch shoots micah after spending years with him. Micah also killed miss grimshaw, and …8. Wagwan piffting23 · 9/6/2020. I think it’s a combination of knowing Micah was a rat and revenge for Arthur. After eight years, Dutch has almost certainly come to terms with the fact that Micah betrayed him. Even in 1899, by the end, he probably knew, as he doesn’t follow Micah. Dutch was the creator of the Van der Linde gang, …Nov 8, 2018 ... I like to believe Dutch didn't shoot Micah for John or Sadie. He did it for Arthur. 27:47. Go to channel · Red Dead Redemption 2 & 1 - All Gang ... Dutch felt guilty for what Micah did and gave John the benefit of the doubt - as they were both there to kill Micah. But by RDR John is working for the Government - something Dutch cannot abide. John is hunting former VDL members, including Dutch. That makes John as much of a betrayer in Dutch's eyes as Micah ever was. Like it pisses me off. Dutch and Micah should have been killed from the get go And why did he even take Dutch’s orders from the beginning of chapter 6. He already didn’t trust him. Kill Micah, kill Dutch, and tell the rest of the crew that you did it because all of shit the happened to them was there fault. Everyone trusts Arthur. Dutch’s main thing was loyalty, he wanted the whole gang to stay with him, in highlight of his speech in chapter 1. But it just doesn’t make sense. in the good ending, dutch turns his back on Micah. but then in the epilogue, dutch shoots micah after spending years with him. Micah also killed miss grimshaw, and …He came to his senses. Finally realized, after seeing John again, that Micah was no good. Dutch had gone to see Micah with the intent to kill him, that's why he says to John that …

Dutch was like a teacher to him. He even said that. He as well as Arthur believed that Micah turned Dutch against the gang when he was in a bad spot. They believe Micah was the true villain. Also that Dutch killed Micah and as he walked away he didn’t see much point to shoot him. Dutch goes along with it because he hates Micah and is just waiting for an opportunity to kill him. Micah doesn't pick up on this because he's a sociopath who thinks he's much smarter than he actually is, and doesn't realize that he isn't fooling Dutch anymore. John is the complication, because even though Dutch hates Micah, he also hates John. I think Micah admired Dutch to a certain point, because of the control and power he had as a leader, but throughout the whole game, he constantly keeps bringing up going back for the Blackwater money and Dutch keeps shutting him down. Mjr1985. • 1 yr. ago. Micah loves only Micah, and his guns.Instagram:https://instagram. ts4rent clt100 pounds to dollarstiktok spanish song 2023returns org crossword clue Dutch shoots Micah because he owes that to Arthur, in a way Dutch gains his redemption by shooting the man responsible for the downfall of his gang and the death of his surrogate son.Dutch knew Micah was the rat who betrayed him and sold out the gang. Why did John shoot Micah? Micah Bell – Jointly killed by Dutch van der Linde and …He came to his senses. Finally realized, after seeing John again, that Micah was no good. Dutch had gone to see Micah with the intent to kill him, that's why he says to John that … spectrum stba 3802the goddard school hiring Also, as for why Dutch killed Micah, I believe he always intended to kill him. In the years after the events surrounding Arthur's death, he probably realised himself that Arthur was right. Micah was the rat. Remember, when John asks Dutch why he was there, he replies "Same as you, I suppose." Dutch and John both came to kill Micah. At the same time, he didn’t stop Micah from killing Arthur. Because above all, Dutch looked out for Dutch and riding with Micah meant he could continue to live the outlaw life he loved so much and secure the money he’d been standing away, etc. He does the same when John/Sadie/Charles have Micah cornered. It’s only THEN that he kills Micah ... best clan boss champions John eventually undermines this in the same exact way Jack does: he picks up Arthur's guns and kills Micah, ... Dutch kills Micah, the Pinkertons still investigate and eventually find out that a 'John Marston' bought a farm in West Elizabeth. He was always going to get caught. At least this way he saved 2 of his friends.I'm assuming because he had years to reflect on how things went south for his "family," that he was the primary cause, that Micah was a rat, and that Micah had devolved into a full blown murderer during their time together. Maybe Dutch felt he didn't deserve the money, or that John deserved it more. Maybe he just wanted to be done with it all.Related: Why Red Dead Redemption 3 Is Almost A Certainty. The mission reportedly got off to a good start, but it was not long until the entire gang was swarmed by Pinkertons. Players learn that, in the heat of the fight, Dutch killed an innocent woman, something players later realize is not out of character for Dutch. …